This post is about one of my favorite topics: academic peer review. I have written about it before, comparing different fields , and suggesting alternatives . Today I will state my analysis of some classic characteristics that I think most reviews of low quality share. I am writing this in the hope that it will be helpful to people just entering the process. It is often not until much later in their careers that they begin to analyze the defects and recognize them and acquire

This post is a review of the book Lise Meitner: A Life in Science by Ruth Lewin Sime. Meitner was the first woman to be a full professor in Germany, a post she later lost due to being Jewish, and was also unjustly denied a Nobel prize in chemistry for her work on nuclear fission. The book is quite substantial, at 417 pages. It divides naturally into three parts. The first part deals with her birth and childhood in Vienna. The author does a great job of describing the milieu

This is a post about my spring break trip to Dublin, where I was visiting the physics department at Trinity College. My first time in Ireland, and though I did not get to see the beautiful countryside, I was most impressed by Dublin city itself. There's a lot to see, the culture is preserved well and proudly, and the people are very friendly. My tourism could be categorized into three classes: Science : The great mathematician Hamilton was Irish and he is commemorated in seve

This is a review of the Princeton Companion to Mathematics. This book was forwarded to me by a friend. It is about a thousand pages long, so not a quick read, and in fact perhaps a book to be dipped into only occasionally (the book claims the original aim was to provide bedtime reading). The writing is highly accessible. Most of the material should be clear to high school graduates, some of it might require a college education. The book is divided into eight chapters. The mai